1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash

1978 Soviet aircraft accident

55°23′41″N 38°51′38″E / 55.39472°N 38.86056°E / 55.39472; 38.86056AircraftAircraft typeTupolev Tu-144DOperatorAeroflotRegistrationСССР-77111Flight originRamenskoye AirportDestinationRamenskoye AirportOccupants8Passengers0Crew8Fatalities2Survivors6

The 1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash occurred during a test flight of a Tupolev Tu-144 on 23 May 1978. The aircraft suffered a fuel leak, which led to an in-flight fire in the right wing, forcing the shutdown of two of the aircraft's four engines. One of the two remaining engines subsequently failed, forcing the crew to make a belly landing in a field near Yegoryevsk, Moscow Oblast. Two flight engineers were killed in the ensuing crash, but the remaining six crew members survived. The accident prompted a ban on passenger flights of the Tu-144, which had already been beset by numerous problems, leading to a lack of interest that ultimately resulted in the Tu-144 program's cancellation.

Aircraft and crew

The aircraft was a supersonic Tupolev Tu-144D, registered СССР-77111, built at the Voronezh Aircraft Production Association facility and destined for Soviet flag carrier Aeroflot. It had first flown on 27 April 1978 and completed test flights on 12 May, 16 May, and 18 May, as well as another test flight earlier on the day of the accident. The accident flight was to have been the aircraft's sixth test flight. Eight crewmembers were on board.^[1]^{[self-published source]}

Accident

The aircraft took off from Ramenskoye Airport near Moscow at 17:30 local time on 23 May 1978. The crew intended to perform a series of tests on the aircraft's generators, engines, cabin airtightness, and controllability at 12,000 metres (39,000 ft). Following the completion of the initial series of tests, the crew descended to 3,000 metres (9,800 ft) to test the aircraft's auxiliary power unit (APU). At 18:44:44 local time, the crew started the APU. Shortly thereafter, at 18:49:15, the crew shut off the APU. Nine seconds later, a fire alarm was triggered; the number 3 engine was shut down at 18:49:31. The crew decided to attempt a return to Ramenskoye Airport. At 18:51:14, the number 4 engine shut down. The crew subsequently noticed a burning smell and thick smoke in the cabin. The number one engine then shut down at 18:53:27; with three of the aircraft's four engines shut down, it was impossible to return to the airport. At 18:55:18, the aircraft belly landed in a field in Yegoryevsky District, roughly 46 kilometres (29 mi; 25 nmi) from Ramenskoye Airport. The aircraft touched down with the landing gear retracted, at a speed of approximately 380 km/h (210 kn; 240 mph). The nose cone collapsed on impact, penetrating a compartment in which two flight engineers were seated and killing them both, while the remaining six crewmembers survived the crash. It was not until about an hour after the crash that the fire was extinguished by firefighters.^[2]

Investigation

The aircraft crash investigation mainly focused on a fuel leak caused by fatigue failure in the wing's fuel pipeline, particularly in the power plant zone, due to the breakdown of an experimental temperature sensor pipe. The official report concluded the fuel leak likely started at 18:18 hours at a rate of 220 kg/min, totaling an estimated 8000 kg fuel loss. This was due to a loss of seal integrity in connection elements or fuel pipelines. The ignited APU sparked fuel vapor, leading to a fire and engine failure^[3]

After the accident, extensive tests found vibrations from internal fuel flow caused unexpected fatigue damage to the fuel pipelines. These unfamiliar vibrations, up to 1500 Hz compared to the expected 100 Hz, combined with certain pipeline cleaning methods, resulted in the premature wear of the pipeline. Other factors included hydraulic shocks from unusually high pressure. New features in the fuel system for the RD-36-51A APU were critical in causing the disaster.^[3]

During the acceptance test flight, the crew, aware of an uncalibrated fuel system, ignored the fuel gauges and relied on fuel flowmeters. A fatal error was made when they dismissed instrument readings, despite acknowledging significant fuel reserve discrepancies. The real fuel leak led to fuel accumulation in multiple compartments, including the ones above the APU. The crew ignored evident leak signs and did not delay testing schedules.^[3]

An attempt of APU startup, which likely failed due to excess fuel and compressor stall, led to the immediate ignition of fuel across the aircraft. Recorded fire alarm signals from different locations of the aircraft suggest the entire plane was ablaze. Despite challenging emergency conditions, the aircraft managed to land but impacted an unexpected obstacle, causing fatal injuries to flight engineers.^[3]

Aftermath

Measures were implemented to prevent similar accidents. All recognized causes were mitigated, with new methods adopted to improve fuel pipeline durability. Remedies were also found to prevent the hydraulic shocks. These issues were specific to the new elements in the RD-36-51A engine fuel system; the fuel system of the previous variant was found to be unaffected, and passed the tests unmodified.^[3]

The crash resulted in a ban on passenger flights of the Tu-144. Combined with other issues involving the Tu-144, including an earlier crash at the 1973 Paris Air Show and complaints about reliability and passenger comfort, this caused a lack of interest in the Tu-144, which ultimately led to the demise of the Tu-144 program.^[4]

References

^ "Crash of a Tupolev TU-144D in Kladkovo: 2 killed". Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives. Retrieved 14 Nov 2021.
^ "Катастрофа Ту-144Д Воронежского авиазавода в Егорьевском районе Московской области" [Accident of the Tu-144D of Voronezh Aircraft Plant in Yegoryevsky District of Moscow Oblast] (in Russian). airdisaster.ru. Retrieved 3 Dec 2021.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e Bliznyuk, Valentin; et al. (2000). "Катастрофа самолета Ту-144Д № 77111(06-2) 23.05.78". Правда о сверхзвуковых пассажирских самолетах [Reality of supersonic passenger airplanes]. Moscow: Moskovsky Rabochiy. ISBN 5-239-02044-2.
^ Prisco, Jacopo (10 Jul 2019). "Concordski: What ever happened to Soviets' spectacular rival to Concorde?". CNN Style. Retrieved 14 Nov 2021.

Aviation accidents and incidents in 1978 (1978)

Jan 1

Air India Flight 855

Feb 11

Pacific Western Airlines Flight 314

Feb 17

British Army Gazelle downing

Mar 1

Continental Airlines Flight 603

Mar 3

LAV HS 748 accident

Mar 9

China Airlines Flight 831

Mar 13

United Airlines Flight 696

Mar 16

Balkan Bulgarian Airlines Flight 107

Apr 20

Korean Air Lines Flight 902

May 8

National Airlines Flight 193

May 19

Aeroflot Flight 6709

May 23

1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash

Jun 21

Iranian Chinook shootdown

Jun 26

Air Canada Flight 189

Jun 26

Helikopter Service Flight 165

Aug 9

Olympic Airways Flight 411

Aug 30

LOT Polish Airlines Flight 165 hijacking

Sep 3

Air Rhodesia Flight 825

Sep 7

Air Ceylon Avro 748 4R-ACJ bombing

Sep 25

Pacific Southwest Airlines Flight 182

Sep 26

Air Caribbean Flight 309

Sep 30

Finnair Flight 405

Oct 3

Finnish Air Force DC-3 crash

Oct 7

Aeroflot Flight 1080

Oct 21

Valentich disappearance

Nov 15

Loftleiðir Flight 001

Dec 17

Indian Airlines Flight 403

Dec 20

Indian Airlines Flight 410

Dec 21

TWA Flight 541

Dec 22

Cessna 188 Pacific rescue

Dec 23

Alitalia Flight 4128

Dec 28

United Airlines Flight 173

1977 ◄ ► 1979

Aviation accidents and incidents in the Soviet Union

1930s	Osoaviakhim-1 SSSR-V6 Osoaviakhim
1940s	1948 Aeroflot Ilyushin Il-12 crash
1950s	1950 Sverdlovsk plane crash LOT Polish Airlines Flight 232 1957 Kiev mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 04 1958 Aeroflot Tu-104 Kanash crash Aeroflot Flight 315 (1959) Aeroflot Flight 120 Aeroflot Flight 200
1960s	Aeroflot Flight 315 (1960) U-2 incident Aeroflot Flight 207 RB-47 shootdown incident Aeroflot Flight 036 Austrian Airlines Flight 901 Aeroflot Flight 068 Aeroflot Flight 245 Aeroflot Flight 902 Aeroflot Flight 415 Aeroflot Flight 213 (1962) Aeroflot Flight 191 Aeroflot Flight 03 Aeroflot Flight 25 Aeroflot Flight 012 Aeroflot Flight 366 Aeroflot Flight 663 Aeroflot Flight 721 Aeroflot Flight 101/X-20 Aeroflot Flight 542 Aeroflot Flight 513 Aeroflot Flight 99 Aeroflot Flight 065 Aeroflot Flight 2723 Aeroflot Flight 5003 (1967) Aeroflot Flight 2230 Aeroflot Flight L-51 Aeroflot Flight 15 Seaboard World Airlines Flight 253A 1969 Yukhnov mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight N-826
1970s	Aeroflot Flight U-45 Aeroflot Flight 1661 Dymshits–Kuznetsov hijacking affair Aeroflot Flight 3630 Aeroflot Flight 244 22 January 1971 Surgut Aeroflot Antonov An-12 crash 31 January 1971 Surgut Aeroflot Antonov An-12 crash Aeroflot Flight 1969 Aeroflot Flight 1912 Malév Flight 110 Aeroflot Flight 773 Aeroflot Flight N-63 Aeroflot Flight 2174 Aeroflot Flight 1491 Aeroflot Flight 558 Aeroflot Flight 1036 Aeroflot Flight 217 Japan Air Lines Flight 446 Aeroflot Flight 6263 Aeroflot Flight 141 Aeroflot Flight 630 Balkan Bulgarian Airlines Flight 307 Aeroflot Flight 6551 Aeroflot Flight 109 Aeroflot Flight A-13 Aeroflot Flight 3932 Aeroflot Flight 964 Aeroflot Flight 19 Aeroflot Flight 2022 1974 Leningrad Aeroflot Il-18 crash 1974 Surgut mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 2003 Aeroflot Flight 3739 (1976) Aeroflot Flight 909 Aeroflot Flight 1802 Aeroflot Flight A-53 Aeroflot Flight 418 1976 Anapa mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 2415 Aeroflot Flight N-36 Aeroflot Flight 3843 Aeroflot Flight 5003 (1977) 1977 Aeroflot Tupolev Tu-134 hijacking Aeroflot Flight B-2 Aeroflot Flight 6709 Korean Air Lines Flight 902 1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash Iranian Chinook shootdown Aeroflot Flight 1080 Aeroflot Flight 1691 1979 Dniprodzerzhynsk mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 5484
1980s– Dec. 1991	Aeroflot Flight 4225 1981 Pushkin Tu-104 crash Aeroflot Flight 498 1981 Armenia mid-air collision 1981 Zheleznogorsk mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 811 Aeroflot Flight 3603 Aeroflot Flight 8641 Aeroflot Flight 411 Aeroflot Flight 5463 Korean Air Lines Flight 007 Aeroflot Flight 601 Aeroflot Flight 3352 Aeroflot Flight 3519 Aeroflot Flight 7841 1985 Zolochiv mid-air collision Aeroflot Flight 5143 Aeroflot Flight 101/435 Aeroflot Flight 2306 Aeroflot Flight 6502 Aeroflot Flight U-505 Aeroflot Flight N-528 Aeroflot Flight 699 Aeroflot Flight 3739 (1988) 1988 Soviet Air Force Il-76 crash An-24 crash in Navoiy Aeroflot Flight 8556