Momotarō

Momotarō
A bisque doll of Momotarō.
In-universe information
Gender	Male
Origin	Japan
Nationality	Japanese

Momotarō (桃太郎, "Peach Boy") is a popular hero of Japanese folklore. His name is often translated as Peach Boy, but is directly translated as Peach + Tarō, a common Japanese given name. Momotarō is also the title of various books, films and other works that portray the tale of this hero.

There is a popular notion that Momotarō is a local hero of Okayama Prefecture, but this claim was invented in the modern era. This notion is not accepted as consensus in scholarly circles.

Story

The present conventional form of the tale (Standard Type) can be summarized as follows:^[1][2]

Momotarō was born from a giant peach, which was found floating down a river by an old, childless woman who was washing clothes there. The woman and her husband discovered the child when they tried to open the peach to eat it. The child explained that he had been bestowed by the gods to be their son. The couple named him Momotarō, from momo (peach) and tarō (eldest son in the family). When he was just five years old, he was able to cut a big tree with just an old knife.

When he matured into adolescence, Momotarō left his parents to fight a band of Oni (demons or ogres) who marauded over their land, by seeking them out in the distant island where they dwelled (a place called Onigashima or "Demon Island"). En route, Momotarō met and befriended a talking dog, monkey and pheasant, who agreed to help him in his quest in exchange for a portion of his rations (kibi dango or "millet dumplings"). At the island, Momotarō and his animal friends penetrated the demons' fort and beat the band of demons into surrendering. Momotarō and his new friends returned home with the demons' plundered treasure and the demon chief as a captive.

This Standard Type of "Momotarō" was defined and popularized due to them being printed in school textbooks during the Meiji Period.^[3]

This is the result of development of the literary "Momotarō", which had been handwritten and printed since the early Edo period into Meiji.^[2] One significant change is that in most examples of Edo Period literature, Momotarō was not born from a peach, but born naturally to the elderly couple who ate the peach and regained their youth. Such subtypes are classed as kaishun-gata (回春型) "rejuvenation" type, whereas the now conventional subtypes are termed kasei-gata (果生型) "birth from the fruit" type.^[2]

Development in literature

Although the oral version of the story may have emerged during the Muromachi period (1392–1573), it may not have been set down in writing until the Edo period (1603–1867).^[2] The oldest works of Momotaro known to have existed had been dated to the Genroku era (1688–1704) or perhaps earlier.^[4][5]

Edo period

These older texts from around the Genroku era (e.g. Momotarō mukashigatari) are lost,^[5] but surviving examples of later dates, such as the reprint Saihan Momotarō mukashigatari (c. 1777^[a]) purportedly preserve the older tradition, and form the first (most primitive) group of texts according to Koike Tōgorō [ja].^[7] The late date of the reprint has sometimes caused it to be classed as kibyōshi ("yellow cover" book, directed primarily at an adult audience) or later type of kusazōshi literature (intended for a more general audience, including women and children), but it should properly be classed as akahon ("red book") or early type.^[8][b][c]

A second group of texts, which Koike considered to be younger, includes the miniature akahon, Momotarō (『もゝ太郎』), printed in Kyōhō 8 (1723).^[d][12] This miniature book is now considered to be the oldest surviving copy of any written Momotarō story.^[13][14]

Whether belonging to the first or second groups, texts from the Edo Period generally follow the same general plot as the modern standard versions but exhibit certain differences in detail.

Dumpling, kindling, animals

Momotarō is not supplied with kibi dango ("millet dumplings"), but rather with tō dango (とう団子) and other treats in the oldest Genroku era texts and the first group.^[15] In the first group, the old man goes out to cut grass, rather than to cut kindling. The same three companion beasts (pheasant, monkey, then dog) appear in both groups, but in a different order.^[16] Though the order of the animals is not significant to the story, the most common order that appear is the dog, the monkey, and then the pheasant. In nearly every variation, all three animal companions agree to help Momotarō in exchange for a portion of his food. In one variation from the Edo Period, the dog is given half a portion, the monkey willingly comes, and Momotarō threatens the pheasant.

Birth from peach

As noted above, in most of the Edo Period books, peach boy is not born from a peach but from the woman who consumes a peach and grows years younger in age. Both the first and second groups consist entirely of "rejuvenation" types. The "birth from the peach" type examples (such as the version in Takizawa Bakin's 1811 essay Enseki zasshi [ja] "Swallowstone Miscellany") are found among tales that have deviated further, which Koike assigns to a third group of texts.^[16] While "birth from the peach" version has not been confirmed in earlier written texts from the Edo Period, one tantalizing sculpture dating to 1614 depicted a man standing in the middle of a split peach. This purported Momotarō carving at Kehi Shrine in Tsuruga, Fukui was lost during the air raids of 1945.^[e][17]

Momotarō's age

It was noted that the protagonist Momotarō was being drawn progressively younger by artists over the years. In one subjective estimation, Momotarō appeared about age 30-ish until c. 1735, 25-ish up to c. 1800, and 20-ish until the end of Edo Period in 1867.^[18]

Not every text specifies age, but in the version in Kamo no Norikiyo (賀茂規清) (1798–1861)'s Hina no Ukegi (雛迺宇計木) Momotarō's was 15 years and 6 months when he set out on his expedition.^[19][f] And in Momotarō takara no kurairi (c. 1830-40), Momotarō was aged sixteen.^[20][21] The Momotarō in Iwaya Sazanami's version of 1894 was of similar age (15 years old) when he resolved to go to devil island.^[22][g]

Researcher Namekawa Michio [ja] also noticed the trend of Momotarō being depicted younger and younger, and he dubbed the phenomenon "tendency of age diminishment" (低年齢化傾向, teinenreika keikō).^[23][24]

Meiji period

After Japan abandoned the feudal system and entered the Meiji era, Iwaya Sazanami [ja] became a seminal figure in how the Momotaro story was shaped and became familiarized to the Japanese populace. Sazanami was the author of the Momotaro tales in his commercially successful folktale collections, and also a major contributor to the textbook versions.

The "Momotarō" tale was first incorporated into nationalized textbooks for elementary schools by the Meiji government in 1887.^[13][26][27] It was subsequently omitted from the 1st edition of the National Language Reader or Kokugo tokuhon [ja] but reappeared from the 2nd edition onward to the 5th edition.^[13] It has been generally accepted that the 2nd edition reader of 1910 was de facto written by storybook author Iwaya Sazanami, who had joined the Ministry of Education as nonpermanent staff in 1906.^[28][29]

Iwaya had already published a version of "Momotaro" (1894) for his Nihon mukashibanashi (Japanese Folktales), where Momotaro is cast as a military soldier or commander (shōgun) of Great Japan (Dainihon), dispatched on a punitive campaign to quell the ogres who live in the northeast.^[30][31] Older texts took the punishing of oni for granted and dispensed with explaining what crimes the oni committed to deserve condemnation. But in Iwaya's version, the ogres were explicitly stated as being evil beings, who devoured the "poor people" and taken "plunder" from the Emperor's land of Japan (Ozaki's translation^[32]), thus morally justifying Momotaro's expedition.^[31][33] It has been suggested these ogres represented the Qing dynasty of China since the publication occurred in 1895, which saw the outbreak of the Sino-Japanese War.^[34]

Taishō and Shōwa eras

From the 3rd edition National Language Reader (1918–1932) onwards (until the end of World War II), "Momotaro" has occupied the spot of the last tale in Book 1 of these nationalized elementary textbook series.^[28] Teachers in essays submitted in 1917 stated that the perception of the Momotaro tale was shifting, so that they were seen as containing lessons of assertiveness and helping in the material advancement of one's country.^[35] There was criticism from the liberalism side, for example, the novelist Yamamoto Yūzō (1925) protesting that the oni were being punished for no apparent reason, and is "tantamount to telling [children] to think of foreigners as oni".^[36]

In the early Shōwa era, after Emperor Hirohito assumed the throne, Momotarō continued to be used to instill patriotism (or the teachings of the Rescript on Education) pupils with the 4th edition National Language Reader (1933–1938) which begins with the picture of the cherry blossom.^[37] The "Momotarō" of the 4th edition was modified so that the oni now stated "We will no longer torment the people nor take things. Please spare our lives", and forfeits their treasures out of their own volition, thus addressing the foregoing issues (i.e., Momotarō accused of attacking oni for no legitimate reason).^[38]

The use of Momotarō in wartime propaganda against the U.S. and its Allies was discussed extensively by John W. Dower in his book War Without Mercy (1986). Dower is credited with coining the term "Momotarō paradigm" in this respect.^[39][40] Momotarō disappeared from Japanese textbooks at the end of World War II.^[41]

Oral variants

The story has some regional variations in oral telling.

In some variants, a red and white box are seen floating down the river, and when the red box is chosen to be recovered, Momotarō is found inside. These may be a red box and a black box, or the box may contain a peach inside. These types are often seen in the northern parts of Japan (Tōhoku and Hokuriku regions).^[13][42]

Or Momotarō may exhibit the characteristic of the lazy protagonist in the Netarō [ja] "Sleeping Boy" stories. These subtypes have been collected mainly in the Shikoku and Chūgoku regions.^[43][44]

There are variances about the Momotarō's process of growth; one is that he grew up to meet the expectation of the old couple to be a fine boy. Another is that he grew up to be a strong but lazy person who just sleeps all day and does not do anything. It is possible that the Momotarō being a fine boy version is more famous to give lessons to children. Nowadays, Momotarō is one of the most famous characters in Japan, as an ideal model for young kids for his kind-heartedness, bravery, power, and care for his parents.

Grown up, Momotarō goes on his journey to defeat the demons when he hears about the demons of the Onigashima (demon island). In some versions of the story, Momotarō volunteered to go help the people by repelling the demons, but in some stories he was forced by the townspeople or others to go on a journey. However, all the stories describe Momotarō defeating the Oni and living 'happily ever after' with the old couple.

Claims as local hero

Momotarō now enjoys popular association with Okayama City or its prefecture, but this association was only created in the modern era.^[45] The publication of a book by Nanba Kinnosuke entitled Momotarō no Shijitsu (1930) for example helped the notion of Momotarō's origins in Okayama to gain wider familiarity.^[46] Still, even as late as the antebellum period before World War II (1941–1945), Okayama was considered only the third contender behind two other regions known as Momotarō's homeland.^[47]

The demon island (Onigashima (鬼ヶ島)) of the story is sometimes associated with Megijima Island, an island in the Seto Inland Sea near Takamatsu, due to the vast manmade caves found there.^[48][49]

Inuyama, Aichi has Momotarō Shrine [ja] with a legend associated with it.^[50][51] In the 1920s and 1930s, lyricist Ujō Noguchi wrote three "folk songs" for the locality alluding to the Momotaro legend.^[51][h]

English translations

The story has been translated into English many times. "The Adventures of Little Peachling" appeared in A.B. Mitford's Tales of Old Japan in 1871. William Elliot Griffis published a version in 1880, which remained obscure even to researchers, even though English translations in subsequent decades apparently borrowed from Griffis's phraseology and use of idiom, sometimes even copying outright.^[52][53]

Rev. David Thompson's translation as "Little Peachling" appeared as the first volume of Hasegawa Takejirō's Japanese Fairy Tale series in 1885.^[54][55] A second edition appeared in 1886, with a different set of illustrations, drawn by Kobayashi Eitaku^[56][57]

Susan Ballard included the tale in Fairy Tales from Far Japan (1899).

Yei Theodora Ozaki included a loosely translated version in her Japanese Fairy Tales (1903); Ozaki's retellings were based on a version by "Sadanami sanjin" (sic., i.e., Sazanami Iwaya [ja]).^[58][59][53] Ozaki was credited with spreading Japanese folktales to the English-speaking nations by researchers such as Teiji Seta [ja].^[i][53]

There was another English translation that used the same source as Ozaki and published around the same time, namely, "The Story of Peach-Boy" in Iwaya's Fairy Tales of Old Japan (1903, repub. 1914) translated by Hannah Riddell.^{[60][61][29][j]} The translation of the collection was a collaborative effort with other translators, such as Fanny B. Greene, Tsuda Umeko and others. This latter effort was acknowledged by Iwaya himself.^[62][53][63]

Teresa Peirce Williston in her Japanese Fairy Tales, Second Series, in 1911.

The tale was translated as Peach-Prince and the Demons and included in the compilation Fairy stories my children love best of all, although the compiler did not indicate its Japanese origin.^[64]

Momotarō's Song

The popular children's song about Momotarō titled Momotarō-san no Uta (Momotarō's Song) was first published in 1911; the text's author is unattributed, while the melody was written by Teiichi Okano. The first two stanzas, with romanization and translation, are given below.^[65]

1. ^ Antoni (1991), pp. 163–164.
2. ^ ^{a b c d} Kahara (2004), p. 39.
3. ^ Kahara (2004), p. 39, Kahara (2010), p. 53:
4. ^ Tierney (2005), p. 143.
5. ^ ^{a b} Namekawa (1981), p. 25.
6. ^ Yamasaki (2018), pp. 51–53.
7. ^ Koike (1967), pp. 23, 28ff, Koike (1972), pp. 24ff, the first (dai-ichi keitō) group of texts.
8. ^ Yamasaki (2018), p. 53.
9. ^ Yamasaki (2018), p. 52.
10. ^ Yoshida, Teruji 吉田暎二 (1971) [1965], Ukiyoe jiten 浮世絵事典 (in Japanese), vol. 2, Gabundo, p. 27 8
11. ^ Kumooka (2016), p. 34ff.
12. ^ Koike (1972), pp. 19ff. 24ff/
13. ^ ^{a b c d} Kahara (2010), p. 53.
14. ^ Yamasaki (2018), p. 57.
15. ^ Koike (1967), p. 21, Koike (1972), p. 26
16. ^ ^{a b} Koike (1972), pp. 24–28 (comparison chart).
17. ^ Koike (1967), pp. 36–37.
18. ^ ^{a b} Koike (1972), pp. 38–39.
19. ^ Koike (1957), p. 9.
20. ^ Ifuku Sanjin (1830–1840). Momotarō takara no kurairi 桃太郎宝蔵入 (in Japanese). Utagawa Hiroshige, illustr. Sanoya.
21. ^ "Momotaro and the Ogres' Treasure House". Edo Picture Books and Japanisme. National Diet Library. 2018. Retrieved 2019-04-26.
22. ^ Ozaki (1903), p. 249, Iwaya (1904), p. 6, Iwaya (1927), p. 6
23. ^ Namekawa (1981), p. 99.
24. ^ Itō, Gō (2011), "Tezuka is Dead: Manga in Transformation and its Dysfunctional Discourse", Mechademia 6: User Enhanced, translated by Miri Nakamura, Minnesota University Press, p. 122, ISBN 9781452933160
25. ^ Hori, Hikari (2008), Promiscuous Media: Film and Visual Culture in Imperial Japan, 1926-1945, Cornell University Press, p. 251 (Note 39 to pages 165–173), ISBN 9781501709524
26. ^ Torigoe (1983), p. 3, cited by Hori in English.^[25]
27. ^ Namekawa (1981), p. ii, cited by Reider (2010), p. 108 in English.
28. ^ ^{a b} Kahara (2010), p. 55.
29. ^ ^{a b c} Rogala, Jozef (2001). A Collector's Guide to Books on Japan in English. Taylor & Francis. pp. 102–103. ISBN 9781873410912.
30. ^ Kahara (2004), p. 47, Kahara (2010), p. 66
31. ^ ^{a b} Reider (2010), p. 109.
32. ^ Ozaki (1903), p. 250.
33. ^ Koike (1972), pp. 28–29.
34. ^ Tierney (2005), pp. 118, 263
35. ^ Kahara (2010), p. 55, citing Maruyama (1917), p. 17 and Kinoshita (1917), p. 127
36. ^ Kahara (2010), p. 55, citing Yamamoto (1977), collected works, vol. 10, pp. 288ff
37. ^ Antoni (1991), pp. 161–162, 179.
38. ^ Kahara (2010), pp. 51 and English abstract.
39. ^ Kahara (2010).
40. ^ Antoni (1991), pp. 165–167.
41. ^ Reider (2010), p. 108, note 4.
42. ^ Seki (1978), pp. 81–83.
43. ^ Kahara (2004), p. 40, Kahara (2010), p. 53
44. ^ Namekawa (1981), p. 334.
45. ^ Kahara (2004), pp. 51, 61, and passim.
46. ^ Kahara (2004), pp. 44–47.
47. ^ Kahara (2004), p. 51.
48. ^ "Oni-ga-shima(or Megijima)". Archived from the original on 2008-01-10. Retrieved 2010-09-01.
49. ^ "Megi-jima/Ogi-jima". Takamatsu City Web Site. Archived from the original on 2010-07-31. Retrieved 2010-09-01.
50. ^ Namekawa (1981), p. 42, 461.
51. ^ ^{a b} Michihito, Higashi 東道人 (1995) [1965], Noguchi Ujō to minyō no tabi 野口雨情詩と民謡の旅 (in Japanese), Tōseisha, p. 496, ISBN 9784924440319
52. ^ Griffis (1880), pp. 62–71.
53. ^ ^{a b c d} Herring (1988), p. 100.
54. ^ Momotaro, or Little Peachling, translated by David Thompson [ダビッド・タムソン], Kobunsha, 1885
55. ^ Kok, J. P. Filedt; Heijbroek, Jan Frederik (1990), The Age of Yoshitoshi: Japanese Prints from the Meiji and Taishō Periods : Nagasaki, Yokohama and Kamigata Prints : Recent Acquisitions, Rijksprentenkabinety, p. 91, ISBN 9789061791126
56. ^ Momotaro, or Little Peachling, translated by David Thompson [ダビッド・タムソン], T. Hasegawa, 1886
57. ^ Sharf, Frederic Alan (1994), Takejiro Hasegawa: Meiji Japan's Preeminent Publisher of Wood-block-illustrated Crepe-paper Books, Peabody Essex Museum, p. 63
58. ^ Herring (1988), p. 100: "..»Sadanami«. This name is a misprint of the nom de plume of Sazanami Iwaya".
59. ^ Ozaki (1903), p. v.
60. ^ Iwaya ed. & Riddell tr. (1914) "The Story of Peach-Boy".
61. ^ ^{a b} "Momotarô: The Story of Peach-Boy". One Hundred Japanese Books for Children (1868–1945). International Institute for Children's Literature, Osaka. Retrieved 7 April 2020.
62. ^ Iwaya (1904), foreword.
63. ^ Reider (2010), p. 240.
64. ^ Shimer, Edgar Dubs. Fairy stories my children love best of all. New York: L. A. Noble. 1920. pp. 73-79. [1]
65. ^ "d-score 楽譜 - 桃太郎 ---- 文部省唱歌／岡野貞一". www.d-score.com.
66. ^ Kahara (2010), p. 66.
67. ^ Tierney (2010), p. 118.
68. ^ "Iwaya Sazanami, Japan: An Illustrated Encyclopedia. Kodansha. 1993. 1:644.
69. ^ Kahara (2004), p. 47.
70. ^ Kamada, Laurel D. (2010). Hybrid Identities and Adolescent Girls, Being "Half in Japan". Multilingual Matters. p. 37. ISBN 9781847692320.
71. ^ Dower (1993), p. 253.
72. ^ Reider (2010), pp. 107ff

• Antoni, Klaus (1991). "Momotaro and the Spirit of Japan". Asian Folklore Studies. 50: 160–161.
• Dower, John W (1993) [1986]. War Without Mercy: Race & Power In the Pacific War. W.W. Norton & Co. ISBN 0-394-50030-X.
• "Peach-Prince, and the Treasure Island". Japanese Fairy World: Stories From the Wonder-Lore of Japan. Translated by Griffis, William Elliot. Schenectady, N. Y.: James H. Barhyte. 1880. pp. 62–71.
• Herring, Ann King (1988). "Early Translations of Japanese Fairy-Tales and Children's Literature". Phaedrus: 97–112.
• Iwaya, Sazanami [in Japanese], ed. (1904), Momotarō 桃太郎, Kōtei Nihon mukashibanashi, 1 (in Japanese)
• ——, ed. (1927). "Momotarō" 桃太郎. Nihon otogibanashishū 日本お伽噺集 (in Japanese). Settai Komura (illustr.). ARS. pp. 3–15.
• ——, ed. (1914) [1903]. "Momotarō: The Story of Peach-Boy". Iwaya's Fairy tales of old Japan 和英對譯 日本昔噺 英對合本. Translated by Riddell, Hannah. Tokyo: Bunyodo Tomita. pp. 35–. online via HathiTrust. Part 1 of 12. Unpaginated. 42 pp.
• Kahara, Nahoko 加原奈穂子 (2004). "From Folktale Hero to Local Symbol: The Transformation of Momotaro (the Peach Boy) in the Creation of a Local Culture". Waseda Journal of Asian Studies. 25: 35–61.
• —— (2010). "昔話の主人公から国家の象徴へ―「桃太郎」パラダイムの形成―" [From Folktale Hero to National Symbol: the making of Momotarō paradigm in Japanese Modern Age]. Bulletin, Faculty of Music, Tokyo National University of Fine Arts & Music (in Japanese and English). 36: 51–72.
• Koike, Tōgorō 小池藤五郎 (1957), "Tokugawa jidai no Momotarō kenkyū ryakki" 徳川時代の桃太郎研究略記, Kokugo to kokubungaku (in Japanese), 34 (8): 1–10
• —— (1967), "Kobunken wo kiso to shita Momotarō setsuwa no kenkyū (I)" 古文献を基礎とした 桃太郎説話の研究(上) [A Study of "Momotaro" : Based on Old Literature (I)], The journal of the Faculty of Letters, Risshō University (in Japanese) (26): 3–39, hdl:11266/2923
• —— (1972), "Kobunken wo kiso to shita Momotarō setsuwa no kenkyū (II)", The Journal of the Faculty of Letters, Risshō University (in Japanese) (45): 3–50
• Kumooka, Azusa 雲岡梓 (2016), "Koten kyōzai to shite no Momotarō" 古典教材としての『桃太郎』 (PDF), Kokugo ronshū (in Japanese), 13, Hokkaido University of Education: 31–40
• Ozaki, Yei Theodora, ed. (1903). "Momotaro, or the story of the Son of a Peach". The Japanese Fairy Book. Archibald Constable & Co. pp. 244–261.
• Namekawa, Michio 滑川道夫 (1981), Momotarō zō no henyō 桃太郎像の変容 (in Japanese), Tokyo Shoten
• Reider, Noriko T. (2010). "6. Oni and Japanese Identity: Enemies of the Japanese Empire in and out of the Imperial Army". Japanese Demon Lore: Oni from Ancient Times to the Present. Utah State University Press. pp. 104–119. doi:10.2307/j.ctt4cgpqc.12. ISBN 9780874217940. JSTOR j.ctt4cgpqc.12.
• Seki, Keigo (1978), 日本昔話大成: 本格昔話 (in Japanese), Nomura Jun'ichi; Ōshima Hiroshi, Kadokawa
• Tierney, Robert (2005). Going native: imagining savages in the Japanese Empire (Ph. D.). Stanford University.
• Tierney, Robert (2010). "The Adventures of Momotarō in the South Seas: Folklore, Colonial Policy". Tropics of Savagery: The Culture of Japanese Empire in Comparative Frame. University of California Press. ISBN 0520947665. JSTOR 10.1525/j.ctt1pp80q.7.
• Torigoe, Shin 鳥越信 (1983), Momotarō no unmei 桃太郎の運命, NHK (reprint Mineruva Shobō, 2004) (in Japanese)
• Yamasaki, Mai 山崎舞 (2018). "Mukashibanashi Momotarō no henten: Saihan Momotarō mukashigatari no shomondai wo chūshin ni" 昔話「桃太郎」の変転―『再板桃太郎昔語』の諸問題を中心に―. Tamamo (in Japanese) (52). Ferris Jogakuin University: 51–67.

FolktalesTextsLegendary creaturesFolklorists