Non-Zionism
Non-Zionism is the political stance of people who neither support nor oppose Zionism.[1]
The trend began in the United States in the first few decades of the 20th century when "an increasingly large section of Americanized Jewish opinion began to shift away from anti-Zionism ... either to pro-Zionism or non-Zionism. ... The non-Zionists were willing to offer the diaspora Jews a Jewish homeland fiscal and diplomatic counsel, not for their own benefit or spiritual comfort but for those Jews who chose to reside there."[2]
Difference from anti-Zionists
Yoram Dinstein gave this distinction: "There is a marked difference between non-Zionism and anti-Zionism. A non-Zionist may challenge the theoretical underpinning of the concept of an 'ingathering of the exiles' in an independent Jewish State. If Jewish, he or she will not choose to live in Israel, nor will he approve or reject the notion of other Jews living there in the Jewish State of Israel ... but anti-Zionists do not find it sufficient to be dissatisfied with a decision made and implemented a long time ago. They are not content with a critical assessment of the situation confined to an historical (and, accordingly, a theoretical) framework. Not merely do they have an adverse opinion about the establishment of Israel in the past, but they contest the legitimacy of Israel as a State in the present time and the future."[3]
Contemporary definitions
Non-position
Non-Zionism has also been defined in terms of a non-position on Zionism. Anthony Frosh has defined a non-Zionist Jew as a Jew "who does not have any particular political relationship (positive or negative) with the State of Israel, or at least little more of a relationship than they would have with some other 3rd party state."[4]
Haredi non-Zionism
Generally, those groups of Ashkenazi (Western) Haredi Jews who participate in the Israeli government but do not believe in religious Zionism are known as "non-Zionists". The most prominent non-Zionist Haredi group is Agudath Israel. This is in contrast to the religious Zionist Mizrachi party (which believed the State of Israel to be the beginning of the redemption); and also in contrast to the anti-Zionist Haredi groups, such as Satmar, Neturei Karta, and Edah HaChareidis, that openly oppose Zionism and have little to no interaction with the State of Israel and no representation in its government. Unlike the older definition, many live in the State of Israel. They tend to be extremely pro-Israel politically, as can be seen in such publications as Mishpacha and Hamodia. Sephardi Haredi Jews may refer to themselves as Zionist.
References
- ^ "FAQ on the Anti-Zionism is Antisemitism Divide". The Times of Israel. 7 February 2022.
The defining feature of non-Zionism is the lack of actively working to aid or harm the Jewish state.
- ^ Egal Feldman, Catholics and Jews in Twentieth-Century America, University of Illinois Press, 2001, p.40.
- ^ Yoram Dinstein, Anti-Semitism, Anti-Zionism and the United Nations in Israel's Yearbook of Human Rights, Faculty of Law, Tel-Aviv University, vol.17, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1987, p.16.
- ^ Frosh, Anthony (August 30, 2009). "Non-Zionism: an Under-Recognised Non-Position". Galus Australis. Archived from the original on 8 October 2011. Retrieved 22 April 2020.
Bibliography
- Gideon Shimoni, From Anti-Zionism to Non-Zionism in Anglo Jewry, 1917–1937, Jewish Journal of Sociology, 28 (1986), pp.19–48
- Gideon Shimoni, The Non-Zionists in Anglo Jewry, 1937–1948.
- Stuart E. Knee, “Jewish Non-Zionism in America and Palestine Commitment 1917-1941,” Jewish Social Studies 39, no. 3 (1977): 209–26.
External links
- Bennett Muraskin, Anti-Zionism and Non-Zionism in Jewish Life—Past and Present,
- v
- t
- e
- Histadrut
- Hovevei Zion
- Bilu
- World Zionist Organization
- Zionist General Council
- Zionist Federation of Germany
- Zionist Organization of America
- Zionist Organization of Canada
- Religious Zionists of America
- Jewish National Fund
- Poale Zion
- Jewish Agency for Israel
- Jewish National Council
- Mizrachi
- Bnei Akiva
- Habonim Dror
- Hashomer Hatzair
- Haganah
- HaNoar HaTzioni
- World Agudath Israel
- Irgun
- Betar
- Lehi
- Jewish Party (Czechoslovakia)
- Jewish Party (Romania)
- Jewish Resistance Movement
- Palmach
- Women's International Zionist Organization
- Hadassah Women's Zionist Organization of America
- Aytzim
- American Zionist Movement
- Am Yisrael Foundation
- Zionist Federation of Great Britain and Ireland
- Institute for Zionist Strategies
- International Fellowship of Christians and Jews
- Nefesh B'Nefesh
- Birthright Israel
timelines
- Yom HaZikaron
- Independence Day
- Jerusalem Day
- Yom HaAliyah
- Herzl Day
- Jabotinsky Day
- Ben-Gurion Day
- Rabin Day
- List of Zionists
- Anti-Zionism
- The Holocaust
- Antisemitism
- New antisemitism
- Not one inch
- Jewish Autonomism
- Jewish emancipation
- Jewish political movements
- Greater Israel
- Muscular Judaism
- Muslim supporters of Israel
- Progressive except Palestine
- Zionism as settler colonialism
- Zionist antisemitism
- Zionist political violence
- Zio (pejorative)
- Ulpan