Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme

Australian Royal Commission

Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme
Commissioner	The Hon. Catherine Holmes AC SC
Inquiry period	18 August 2022 (2022-08-18) – 7 July 2023 (2023-07-07)
Constituting instrument	Royal Commissions Act 1902 (Cth)
Website	robodebt.royalcommission.gov.au

The Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme is a royal commission established on 18 August 2022 by the Australian Government pursuant to the Royal Commissions Act 1902. The Royal Commissioner, Catherine Holmes, released her report on 7 July 2023.^[1]

Background

In June 2020, the Greens and Labor called for a Royal Commission into Robodebt, to 'determine those responsible for the scheme, and its impact on Australians'.^[2]^[3] These calls have been reiterated by university academics,^[4] and by the Australian Council of Social Service (ACOSS), which stated that "although some restitution has been delivered to victims of Robodebt, they have not received justice".^[5]

In May 2022, the final report from the second Senate inquiry into the Robodebt scheme recommended a Royal Commission, "to completely understand how the failures of the Income Compliance Program came to pass, and why they were allowed to continue for so long despite the dire impacts on people issued with debts".^[6]

In June 2020 Labor had stated that only a Royal Commission would be able to obtain the truth about Robodebt.^[7] Labor subsequently budgeted A$30 million in its election costings for the 2022 election for a Royal Commission into the Robodebt scheme.^[8] ACOSS chief executive Cassandra Goldie welcomed this saying "The Robodebt affair was not just a maladministration scandal, it was a human tragedy that resulted in people taking their lives".^[9]

Following Labor's election win,^[10] Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced the Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, with Letters Patent issued by Governor-General David Hurley on 25 August 2022. The Letters Patent appointed former Queensland Supreme Court Justice Catherine Holmes as Royal Commissioner.^[11]^[12]^[13]

Terms of reference

The terms of reference outlined in the Letters Patent require the commissioner to examine:^[14]

The establishment, design and implementation of the Robodebt scheme
The use of third party debt collectors under the Robodebt scheme
Concerns raised following the implementation of the Robodebt scheme
The intended or actual outcomes of the Robodebt scheme

Powers

The powers of Royal Commissions in Australia are set out in the enabling legislation, the Royal Commissions Act 1902 (Cth).

Royal Commissions have powers to issue a summons to a person to appear before the Commission at a hearing to give evidence or to produce documents specified in the summons; require witnesses to take an oath or give an affirmation; and require a person to deliver documents to the Commission at a specified place and time.^[15] A person served with a summons or a notice to produce documents must comply with that requirement, or face prosecution for an offence. The penalty for conviction upon such an offence is a fine of A$1,000 or six months imprisonment.^[16] A Royal Commission may authorise the Australian Federal Police to execute search warrants.^[17]

Reports

The Royal Commissioner was initially required to provide a final report by 18 April 2023, however in February 2023, the reporting date was extended to 30 June 2023.^[11]^[18] It was then extended for a second time with the new due date being 7 July 2023, to allow the commission to make referrals to the newly established National Anti-Corruption Commission, which became operational on 1 July 2023.^[19]

Final report

The final report was released on 7 July 2023. It was three volumes and almost 1,000 pages long, and contained 57 recommendations for improved public policy design and a sealed section recommending the referral of individuals for civil and criminal prosecution.^[20]

The report concluded that the robodebt scheme was "devised without regard to the social security law", and that the use of income averaging in estimating entitlements "was essentially unfair, treating many people as though they had received income at a time when they had not".^[20] It found that public servants at the DHS were aware that the scheme would involve income averaging, but mislead cabinet in neglecting to inform them, and that the former head of the DHS Kathryn Campbell was made aware of the scheme's illegality but "failed to act" by ignoring legal advice. It also criticised former social services minister Scott Morrison, finding that he had "allowed cabinet to be misled" by not investigating the change in position by the DHS on robodebt's requirement for legislative change.^[21]^[22]

The report also criticised the government's "obliviousness to, or worse a callous disregard, of the fact that many welfare recipients had neither the means nor the ability to negotiate an online system" to provide evidence of years old income information in disputing debts. It described the scheme as "crude and cruel mechanism" that "made many people feel like criminals."^[20] It additionally criticised former government services minister Stuart Robert for publicly using false figures to defend robodebt, and what it described as former human service's minister Alan Tudge's "abuse of power" in leaking social security recipient's information to the media.^[22]

Holmes' preface to the report summarises the 57 recommendations: "Some are directed at strengthening the public service more broadly, some to improving the processes of the Department of Social Services and Services Australia. Others are concerned with reinforcing the capability of oversight agencies." Holmes noted however that the effectiveness of the suggested changes hinged on the top-down culture and robustness of the Australian Public Service, and improvements in political rhetoric and social attitudes regarding people receiving welfare payments.^[23]^[24]

Referrals

The report contains a "sealed" section which was not publicly released, which "recommends the referral of individuals for civil action or criminal prosecution". This section was sealed so as not to prejudice any civil or criminal proceedings that may arise.^[1] Several individuals were referred to four separate bodies. Although the Commissioner did not name them, the ABC reported them as the Australian Federal Police, the newly-established National Anti-Corruption Commission, a division of the Law Society, and the Australian Public Service Commissioner.^[25]

In August 2023, the Australian Public Service Commissioner announced that the Royal Commission had referred 16 bureaucrats for investigation of whether their Robodebt actions had breached the public service Code of Conduct.^[26]

Aftermath

In the aftermath of the final report, Kathryn Campbell, secretary of the Department of Human Services from 2011 to 2017, was suspended without pay from her position as a special adviser on the AUKUS nuclear submarine project, a position with a $900,000 salary.^[27] Additionally, a PwC consultant who testified to the Royal Commission was fired in the hours after the final report was released.^[28]

References

^ ^a ^b Holmes, Catherine (7 July 2023). "Report of the Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme". Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme.
^ "Calls for royal commission into robodebt and apology from Morrison government". The Guardian Australia. 2 June 2020. Retrieved 1 May 2022.
^ "Labor calls for royal commission into robodebt scheme". Nine News. 23 June 2020. Retrieved 1 May 2022.
^ "We need a royal commission into robodebt". La Trobe University. 23 June 2020. Retrieved 1 May 2022.
^ "Calls heard again for royal commission into 'horrific' and unlawful robodebt scheme". SBS News. 19 August 2021. Retrieved 1 May 2022.
^ "Chapter 2: A massive failure of public administration". Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 19 May 2022.
^ "Labor bid for robodebt inquiry". www.theaustralian.com.au. 22 June 2020. Retrieved 25 May 2022.
^ "Robodebt Royal Commission". www.alp.org.au. Retrieved 25 May 2022.
^ "Labor pledges royal commission into 'human tragedy' of robodebt if elected". Guardian Australia. 30 April 2022. Retrieved 25 May 2022.
^ "Labor secures majority government despite record non-major party vote and crossbench". the Guardian. 30 May 2022. Retrieved 22 June 2022.
^ ^a ^b "Home". Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme. Australian Government. 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
^ "Robodebt royal commission established to investigate almost $2 billion in unlawful debt claims". ABC News. 25 August 2022. Retrieved 25 August 2022.
^ "Explained: A Robodebt royal commission has been announced. What can we expect next?". www.9news.com.au. Retrieved 27 August 2022.
^ "Letters Patent – plain English". Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme. Australian Government. 18 August 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
^ "Royal Commissions Act 1902 - Sect 2: Power to summon witnesses and take evidence". Austlii.edu.au. Archived from the original on 3 February 2014. Retrieved 23 January 2014.
^ "Royal Commissions Act 1902 - Sect 3: Failure of witnesses to attend or produce documents". Austlii.edu.au. Archived from the original on 3 February 2014. Retrieved 23 January 2014.
^ "Royal Commissions Act 1902 - Sect 4: Search warrants". Austlii.edu.au. Archived from the original on 3 February 2014. Retrieved 23 January 2014.
^ Webber, Miriam (11 May 2023). "Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus extends deadline for final report into robodebt royal commission". The Canberra Times. Archived from the original on 15 May 2023.
^ Karp, Paul; Henriques-Gomes, Luke (6 July 2023). "What is robodebt? Six things to watch for in the royal commission's final report today". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 7 July 2023.
^ ^a ^b ^c Karp, Paul (7 July 2023). "'Crude and cruel' scheme: robodebt royal commission report recommends civil and criminal prosecutions". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 September 2023.
^ Karp, Paul (10 July 2023). "Seven public servants criticised in robodebt report as agencies consider response". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 September 2023.
^ ^a ^b Knaus, Christopher (7 July 2023). "Robodebt royal commission final report: key findings on Scott Morrison, Stuart Robert, Kathryn Campbell and Alan Tudge". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 September 2023.
^ Grattan, Michelle (7 July 2023). "Robodebt royal commissioner makes multiple referrals for prosecution, condemning scheme as 'crude and cruel'". The Conversation. Retrieved 1 September 2023.
^ "Read Catherine Holmes' robodebt royal commission final report". The Mandarin. 7 July 2023. Retrieved 1 September 2023.
^ Lewis, Alexander; Jones (7 July 2023). "Commissioner brands Robodebt 'extraordinary saga' of 'venality, incompetence and cowardice'". ABC News. Retrieved 10 July 2023.
^ Canales, Sarah Basford (3 August 2023). "Robodebt: 16 bureaucrats named in royal commission report face investigation by public service agency". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 5 August 2023.
^ Al Khouri, Chantelle; Brewster, Alex (19 July 2023). "Top bureaucrat behind Robodebt suspended from $900k job". ABC News. Retrieved 20 July 2023.
^ Ravlic, Julian Bajkowski, Tom (7 July 2023). "First robodebt royal commission scalp confirmed at PwC". The Mandarin. Retrieved 20 July 2023.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

External links

Official website

Royal Commissions of the Commonwealth of Australia

1901–1920

1901–1910

1901–1905

to inquire into and report upon the arrangements made for the transport of troops returning from service in South Africa in the S.S. "Drayton Grange" (1902)
on sites for the seat of government of the Commonwealth (1903)
on the Bonuses for Manufactures Bill (1903–1904)
on the butter industry (1904–1905)
on the Navigation Bill (1904–1906)
on the affray at Goaribari Island, British New Guinea, on the 6th of March, 1904 (1904)
on customs and excise tariffs (1904–1907)
on old-age pensions (1905–1906)
on the tobacco monopoly (1905–1906)

1906–1910

on ocean shipping service (1906)
British New Guinea—Royal Commission of inquiry into the present conditions, including the method of government, of the Territory of Papua, and the best means of their improvement (1906–1907)
on secret drugs, cures, and foods (1906–1907)
on postal services (1908–1910)
on insurance (1908–1910)
on stripper harvesters and drills (1908–1909)
on Tasmanian customs leakage (1910–1911)

1911–1920

1911–1912	on the sugar industry (1911–1912) on the pearl-shelling industry (1912–1916) on the fruit industry (1912–1914)
1913–1914	to inquire into certain charges against Mr. Henry Chinn (1913) on Northern Territory railways and ports (1913–1914) on powellised timber (1913–1914) upon the Commonwealth electoral law and administration (1914–1915) on meat export trade (1914) on food supplies and trade and industry during the war (1914)
1915–1916	on mail services and trade development between Australia and the New Hebrides (1915) on Liverpool Military Camp, New South Wales (1915) on the charges made by D. L. Gilchrist concerning the construction of the western section of the Kalgoorlie to Port Augusta Railway (1916) to inquire into and report upon certain charges against the Administrator and other officers of the Northern Territory Administration (1916) on Federal Capital Administration (1916–1917)
1917–1918	on Java and the East Indies, Singapore and the Straits Settlements (1917–1918) on Navy and Defence Administration (1917–1919) on the war—Australian Imperial Force. Report as to number of members fit for active service and number of reinforcements and enlistments required (1918) on Public Service administration, Commonwealth of Australia (1918–1920) upon the public expenditure of the Commonwealth of Australia with a view to effecting economies (1918–1921) on taxation of leasehold estates in Crown lands (1918–1919) on the basic wage (1919–1920)
1919–1920	on the sugar industry (1919–1920) on industrial troubles on Melbourne wharfs (1919–1920) on late German New Guinea (1919–1920) to inquire into complaints by the munition worker passengers to Australia by the transport "Bahia Castillo" (1919) on Northern Territory Administration (1919–1920) on taxation (1920–1923) on the increase of the selling price of coal (1920)

1921–1940

1921–1930

1921–1922	on the matter of uniform railway gauge (1921) on pillaging of ships' cargoes (1921) on Cockatoo Island Dockyard (1921) upon the loyalty to the British Crown of German Nationals resident in Australia whose property is liable to a charge created by the Treaty of Peace Regulations made under the Treaty of Peace (Germany) Act 1919–1920 (1921)
1923–1924	on the circumstances attending the supposed loss at sea of the steamship "Sumatra" (1923) in connection with sugar purchases by the Commonwealth through Mr. W. E. Davies in September and October, 1920 (1923–1924) in connection with joinery supplied to the War Service Homes Commissioner in March, 1920 (1923–1924) on the Navigation Act (1923–1925) on national insurance (1923–1927) on the method for determining the unimproved value of land held under Crown leases (1924–1925) on the assessment of war service disabilities (1924–1925) to inquire into extracts from the reports in Parliamentary Debates of speeches made by Mr. Scullin in the House of Representatives on 7 and 19 August 1924, in relation to land tax matters (1924–1925) on the finances of Western Australia, as affected by Federation (1924–1925)
1925–1926	on health (1925–1926) on Norfolk Island affairs (1926) on certain matters in connexion with the British Phosphate Commission (1926)
1927–1928	on wireless (1927) on the Edie Creek (New Guinea) leases (1927) on the Moving Picture Industry in Australia (1927–1928) on the Constitution (Australia)
1929–1930	on the coal industry (1929) to inquire into allegations affecting members of the Parliamentary Joint Committee of Public Accounts in connexion with claims made by broadcasting companies against the Commonwealth Government (1930)

1931–1940

1931–1935

on Jacob Johnson (1931)
on performing rights (1932–1933)
on taxation (1932–1934)
on mineral oils and petrol and other products of mineral oils (1933–1935)
on the wheat, flour and bread industries (1934–1936)
to inquire into and report upon the circumstances associated with the retirement of Lieutenant-Commander Alan Dermot Casey from the Royal Australian Navy (1934)
to inquire into the monetary and banking systems at present in operation in Australia (1935–1937)

1936–1940

on doctors' remuneration for national insurance service and other contract practice (1938)
regarding the contract for the erection of additions to the General Post Office, Sydney (1939)

1941–1960

1941–1950

to inquire into and report upon the contract or contracts with Abbco Bread Co. Pty. Limited for the supply of bread to the Department of the Army, and other matters (1941)
to inquire into circumstances under which certain public monies were used and to whom, and for what purposes such moneys were paid (1941)
an inquiry into a statement that there was a document missing from the official files in relation to "The Brisbane Line" (1943)
to inquire into and report upon certain transactions of the Sydney Land Sales Control Office, and the Canberra Land Sales Control Office of the Treasury (1947)
to inquire into certain transactions in relation to timber rights in the Territory of Papua-New Guinea (1949)

1951–1960

on the Port Augusta to Alice Springs Railway (1951–1952)
on television (1953–1954)
on espionage (1954–1955)

1961–1980

1961–1970

on alleged improper practices and improper refusal to co-operate with the Victoria Police Force on the part of persons employed in the Postmaster-General's Department in Victoria in relation to illegal gambling (1962–1963)
on loss of HMAS Voyager (1964)
on the statement of Lieutenant Commander Cabban and matters incidental thereto (1967–1968)
into exploratory and production drilling for petroleum in the area of the Great Barrier Reef (1970–1975)

1971–1980

1971–1975

Aboriginal Land Rights Commission (1973–1974)
Australian Post Office Commission of inquiry (1973–1974)
of Inquiry into land tenures (1973–1976)
on petroleum (1973–1976)
of Inquiry into the maritime industry (1973–1976)
Independent Inquiry into Frequency Modulation Broadcasting (1973–1974)
of Inquiry into transport to and from Tasmania (1974–1976)
on Australian Government Administration (1974–1976)
on human relationships (1974–1978)
on intelligence and security (1974–1977)
into alleged payments to maritime unions (1974–1976)
to inquire into and report upon certain incidents in which Aborigines were involved in the Laverton area (1975–1976)
on Norfolk Island (1975–1976)

1975–1980

of Inquiry into drugs (1977–1980)
of Inquiry into matters in relation to electoral redistribution Queensland, 1977 (1978)
of Inquiry into the efficiency and administration of hospitals (1979–1981)
of Inquiry into the viability of the Christmas Island phosphate industry (1979–1980)
on the activities of the Federated Ship Painters and Dockers Union (1980–1984)

1981–2000

1981–1990

1981–1985

of Inquiry into Drug Trafficking (1981–1983)
into the activities of the Australian Building Construction Employees' and Builders Labourers' Federation (1981–1982)
into Australian meat industry (1981–1982)
of Inquiry into the activities of the Nugan Hand Group (1983–1985)
on the use and effects of chemical agents on Australian personnel in Vietnam (1983–1985)
on Australia's security and intelligence agencies (1983–1985)
of Inquiry into compensation arising from social security conspiracy prosecutions (1984–1986)
into British nuclear tests in Australia (1984–1985)
of inquiry into alleged telephone interceptions (1985–1986)

1986–1990

of inquiry into Chamberlain convictions (1986–1987)
into grain storage, handling and transport (1986–1988)
into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (1987–1991)

1991–2000

of Inquiry into the Australian Secret Intelligence Service (1994–1995)
of Inquiry into the leasing by the Commonwealth of accommodation in Centenary House (1994)
of Inquiry into the relations between the CAA and Seaview Air (1994–1996)

2001–2020

2001–2010