Scientific essentialism
Scientific essentialism, a view espoused by Saul Kripke and Hilary Putnam,[1] maintains that there exist essential properties that objects possess (or instantiate) necessarily. In other words, having such and such essential properties is a necessary condition for membership in a given natural kind. For example, tigers are tigers in virtue of possessing a particular set of genetic properties, but identifying (or appearance-based) properties are nonessential properties. If a tiger lost a leg, or didn't possess stripes, we would still call it a tiger. They are not necessary for being a member of the class of tigers.
It is important, however, that the set of essential properties of an object not be used to identify or be identified with that object because they are not necessary and sufficient, but only necessary. Having such and such a genetic code does not suffice for being a tiger. We wouldn't call a piece of tiger tail a tiger, even though a piece of tiger tail contains the genetic information essential to being a tiger.
Other advocates of scientific essentialism include Brian Ellis,[2] Caroline Lierse,[3] John Bigelow,[3] and Alexander Bird.[4]
References
- ^ Hanna, R. (1998). "A Kantian Critique of Scientific Essentialism". Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 58 (3): 497–528. doi:10.2307/2653754. JSTOR 2653754.
- ^ Brian Ellis (July 23, 2007), Scientific Essentialism (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy), Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-0-521-03774-7, OCLC 124025546, OL 7715358M, 0521037743
- ^ a b Bigelow, J.; Ellis, B.; Lierse, C. (1992). "The World as One of a Kind: Natural Necessity and Laws of Nature". The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science. 43 (3): 371–388. doi:10.1093/bjps/43.3.371.
- ^ Alexander Bird (August 31, 2007), Nature's Metaphysics, Oxford University Press, USA, ISBN 978-0-19-922701-3, OL 10145956M, 0199227012
External links
- Scientific essentialism at PhilPapers
- Essentialism at the Indiana Philosophy Ontology Project
- v
- t
- e
- Analysis
- Analytic–synthetic distinction
- A priori and a posteriori
- Causality
- Commensurability
- Consilience
- Construct
- Creative synthesis
- Demarcation problem
- Empirical evidence
- Explanatory power
- Fact
- Falsifiability
- Feminist method
- Functional contextualism
- Ignoramus et ignorabimus
- Inductive reasoning
- Intertheoretic reduction
- Inquiry
- Nature
- Objectivity
- Observation
- Paradigm
- Problem of induction
- Scientific evidence
- Scientific law
- Scientific method
- Scientific pluralism
- Scientific Revolution
- Scientific theory
- Testability
- Theory choice
- Theory-ladenness
- Underdetermination
- Unity of science
- more...
- Coherentism
- Confirmation holism
- Constructive empiricism
- Constructive realism
- Constructivist epistemology
- Contextualism
- Conventionalism
- Deductive-nomological model
- Epistemological anarchism
- Evolutionism
- Fallibilism
- Foundationalism
- Hypothetico-deductive model
- Inductionism
- Instrumentalism
- Model-dependent realism
- Naturalism
- Physicalism
- Positivism / Reductionism / Determinism
- Pragmatism
- Rationalism / Empiricism
- Received view / Semantic view of theories
- Scientific essentialism
- Scientific formalism
- Scientific realism / Anti-realism
- Scientific skepticism
- Scientism
- Structuralism
- Uniformitarianism
- Vitalism
- Criticism of science
- Descriptive science
- Epistemology
- Faith and rationality
- Hard and soft science
- History and philosophy of science
- Normative science
- Protoscience
- Pseudoscience
- Relationship between religion and science
- Rhetoric of science
- Science studies
- Sociology of scientific ignorance
- Sociology of scientific knowledge
Precursors |
---|
- Auguste Comte
- Henri Poincaré
- Pierre Duhem
- Rudolf Steiner
- Karl Pearson
- Charles Sanders Peirce
- Wilhelm Windelband
- Alfred North Whitehead
- Bertrand Russell
- Otto Neurath
- C. D. Broad
- Michael Polanyi
- Hans Reichenbach
- Rudolf Carnap
- Karl Popper
- Carl Gustav Hempel
- W. V. O. Quine
- Thomas Kuhn
- Imre Lakatos
- Paul Feyerabend
- Ian Hacking
- Bas van Fraassen
- Larry Laudan