Symmetric federalism
Symmetric federalism refers to a federal system of government in which each constituent state to the federation possess equal powers. In a symmetric federalism no distinction is made between constituent states.[1] This is in contrast to asymmetric federalism, where a distinction is made between constituent states.
Examples
Australia
Australia is a symmetric federation, as each of the 6 states are given equal levels of autonomy and representation in the Parliament, aside from differences in their representation in the House of Representatives that are due to their different populations.[2] Australia also has territories, which are autonomous divisions with devolved powers, but are subordinate to the federal government and organized in varying ways.
United States
The United States is a symmetric federation, as each of the 50 states in the Union has the same standing and powers under the United States Constitution. This was affirmed in Coyle v. Smith[3] when the U. S. Supreme Court declared a provision of the Oklahoma Enabling Act which required the State capital be located in Guthrie, Oklahoma until at least 1913, as being unconstitutional. However, the U.S. has a number of insular areas directly under the control of the U. S. federal government, with various degrees of autonomy. The District of Columbia is not an insular area, but it is also directly controlled by the federal government with limited autonomy.
References
- v
- t
- e
- History
- Articles of Confederation
- Mount Vernon Conference
- Annapolis Convention
- Philadelphia Convention
- The Federalist Papers
- Anti-Federalist Papers
- Massachusetts Compromise
- Virginia Ratifying Convention
- New York Circular Letter
- Hillsborough Convention
- Fayetteville Convention
- Rhode Island ratification
- Drafting and ratification timeline
- Admission to the Union
- Appointments
- Appropriations
- Assistance of Counsel
- Case or Controversy
- Citizenship
- Commerce
- Compact
- Compulsory Process
- Confrontation
- Congressional enforcement
- Contingent Elections
- Contract
- Copyright and Patent
- Double Jeopardy
- Due Process
- Elections
- Engagements
- Equal Protection
- Establishment
- Exceptions
- Excessive Bail
- Ex Post Facto
- Extradition
- Free Exercise
- Free Speech
- Fugitive Slave
- Full Faith and Credit
- General Welfare
- Guarantee
- House Apportionment
- Impeachment
- Import-Export
- Ineligibility
- Militia
- Natural-born citizen
- Necessary and Proper
- No Religious Test
- Oath or Affirmation
- Original Jurisdiction
- Origination
- Pardon
- Petition
- Postal
- Presentment
- Presidential Electors
- Presidential succession
- Privileges and Immunities
- Privileges or Immunities
- Recess appointment
- Recommendation
- Self-Incrimination
- Speech or Debate
- Speedy Trial
- State of the Union
- Supremacy
- Suspension
- Take Care
- Takings
- Taxing and Spending
- Territorial
- Title of Nobility (Foreign Emoluments)
- Treaty
- Trial by Jury
- Vesting (Legislative / Executive / Judicial)
- Vicinage
- War Powers
- Balance of powers
- Concurrent powers
- Constitutional law
- Criminal procedure
- Criminal sentencing
- Dormant Commerce Clause
- Enumerated powers
- Equal footing
- Executive privilege
- Implied powers
- Incorporation of the Bill of Rights
- Judicial review
- Nondelegation doctrine
- Plenary power
- Preemption
- Reserved powers
- Saxbe fix
- Separation of church and state
- Separation of powers
- Symmetric federalism
- Taxation power
- Unitary executive theory
and legacy
- National Archives
- Independence National Historical Park
- Constitution Day
- Constitution Gardens
- Constitution Week
- National Constitution Center
- Scene at the Signing of the Constitution (painting)
- A More Perfect Union (film)
- USS Constitution
- Bibliography
- Worldwide influence